Planck statement also violates the clausius statement and vice versa. Thermodynamics kelvinplanck statement physics forums. Violation of one statement leads to the violation of another statement. Kelvin and planck statement it is impossible to construct a device that will operate in a cycle and produce no other effect than the raising of a weight and the exchange of heat with a single reservoir. Thus, the kelvinplanck statement of the second law is violated.
Equivalence of kelvin and clausius statements of 2nd law. Classical approach to 2 law for cm georgia institute of. Apparently, the kelvin planck statement and the clausius statement of the second law of thermodynamics are altogether different. This is thus in violation of the kelvin planck statement of the second law. Kelvin planck and clausius statements look different but both are are the parallel statements of second law of thermodynamics. To prove that violation of the kelvin planck statement leads to a violation of the clausius statement, let us assume that kelvin planck statement is incorrect. Kelvin planck statement it is impossible to construct a. It is immediate to demonstrate that the inverse is also true. Q q w h r cyclic device e joules heating process fig.
Now suppose we have a heat engine which can convert heat into work without rejecting heat anywhere else. The two statements of the second law may not appear to have anything to do with one another, but in fact each one implies the other. Apr 10, 2018 in this video, we have shown the equivalence of kelvin planck and clausius statements. As is usually done, we adopt that by definition the heat reservoirs are internally reversible. Are the kelvin and clausius statements of second law of. Kelvin planck statement it is impossible to construct a system which when from lgb 10102 at university of kuala lumpur. Proof equivalence of kelvinplanck and clausius statements. Clausis statement and equivalence to planck statement. Clausius an engine operating in a cycle cannot transfer heat from a cold reservoir to a hot reservoir without some other. Pdf what is the real clausius statement of the second law of. Explain how this process can still be consistent with the kelvin planck statement of the second law of thermodynamics. The two statements of the second law are equivalent. Apr 23, 2012 the kelvin planck statement of the second law of thermodynamics reads as follows.
It is impossible to transfer heat from lower temperature to higher temperature reservoir in heat pump. When it comes to rest, potential energy of mass in its initial condition would. It is impossible to construct a device which operates on a cycle and whose sole effect is the transfer of heat from a cooler body to a hotter body. In other words, the violation of kelvin plank statement leads to. So, let me introduce the other equivalent statements of the same law.
We also previously noted that temperature is always positive. A formulation of the second law of thermodynamics, stating it is not possible that, at the end of a cycle of changes, heat has been transferred from a. Classical approach to 2nd law for cm l start with observations about the ability to build devices thermodynamic cycles l clausius statement of 2nd law. Thus, it is impossible to produce a heat engine, whose sole effect is to absorb energy in the form of heat from a heat source and produce an equal amount of work.
Finally, we defined entropy as a measure of disorder. However here i am trying to give some more details for reference. Engineering thermodynamicssecond law wikibooks, open books. Let us suppose that the kelven planck statement is incorrect. The two statementsof the second lawmay not appear to have anything to do with one another, but in fact each one implies the other. Equivalence of kelvinplanck and clausius statements. The coefficient of performance of an irreversible refrigeration cycle is always less than the coefficient of performance of a reversible refrigeration cycle when both exchange energy by heat transfer with the same two reservoirs. Kelvinplanck no process is possible whose sole result is the con version of heat completely into work. The equivalence of statement will be proved by logic and violation of one statement leads to violation of second statement and vice versa of it. The top line shows yellow engines representing hypothetical engines violating each of the two statements of the second law. In second law of thermodynamics, it is said that these two statement are equivalent and inverse to each other.
Clausius statement it is impossible to construct a device that would operate in a cycle which extracts heat from a low temperature reservoir and supplies to a high temperature reservoir without any external agency. Identifying pmm2 by kelvinplanckclausius statement a pmm2 according to kelvinplanck statement is a device that. It is impossible for an engine working in a cycle to produce no other effect than that of extracting heat from a reservoir and performing an equivalent amount of work. Equivalence of kelvinplank and clausius statements.
It is impossible to construct a cyclic heat engine that produces no other effect but the absorption of energy from a hot reservoir and the production of an equal amount of work. In this video, we have shown the equivalence of kelvinplanck and clausius statements. Kelvin planck statement of the second law figure 5. Equivalence of kelvinplanck and clausius statements brainkart. Identifying pmm2 by kelvinplanck clausius statement a pmm2 according to kelvinplanck statement is a device that. What are the kelvinplanck and clausius statements of the. Equivalence of the kelvinplanck statement of the second law. Request pdf equivalence of the kelvinplanck statement of the second law.
Therefore efficiency of a heat engine is always less that 100%. Introduction second law of thermodynamics some important definitions kelvin planck statement clausius statement equivalence. Using the kelvin planck statement of the second law of thermodynamics, demonstrate the following corollaries. Violation of clausius statement thermodynamics, mechanical. This statement operates with the term thermal reservoir or single reservoir. Clausius fit 0 process is possible whose sole result is the trans fer oj heat from a colder to a hotter body.
Second law of thermodynamics alternative statements. These two statements look very different but are equivalent to each other i. For a cycle here q is the net heat added to the system, q net. In an isothermal expansion of a gas the energy absorbed by the gas is completely converted to work. A violation of kelvin planck statement leads to a violation of the clausis statement too and viceversa. Basically, it says that thermodynamic cycles cannot completely convert heat into work.
Equivalence of the kelvin plank and clausius statements. Equivalence of kelvinplanck and clausius statements violation of clausius statementviolation. True the carnot efficiency also limits the efficiency of wind turbines in generating electricity. Then, the kelvinplanck statement implies the principle of increase of entropy. Yash desai has already answered this question beautifully and deserves an upvote. What is the real clausius statement of the second law of. What is the proof of equivalence of the clausius and plank kelvin.
Lets combine this non kelvin engine with a heat pump which we know to exist there is a non clausius engine. One of the goals of this paper is to provide such a framework. Oct 21, 2016 equivalence of the clausius and kelvin planck versions of the 2nd law. This equivalence can be demonstrated by showing that. Clausius statement of the second law of thermodynamics. Equivalence of the kelvinplanck statement of the second law and. Equivalent of kelvin plank and clausius statement the kelvin plank and clausius statements of the second law and are equivalent in all the respect.
Refrigerators and heat pumps a refrigerator is basically a cyclic heat engine run backwards. The most logical statement is the one involving entropy increase. Therefore, the disorder of the system increases, which is the same as the first statement. The equality holds for the reversible process and the inequality holds for the irreversible process. The phrase in a cycle does not apply in this situation, so the second law does not forbid heat being converted entirely into work. A mass suspended by a cable at elevation z i would fall when released. The kelvinplanck statement or the heat engine statement of the second law of thermodynamics states that it is impossible to devise a cyclically operating heat engine, the effect of which is to absorb energy in the form of heat from a single thermal reservoir and to deliver an equivalent amount of work.
What is the relation between clausius and kelvinplanck. May 19, 2015 kelvin plank an engine operating in a cycle cannot transform heat into work without some other effect on its environment. Then, by the clausis inequality the change in entropy s, must also be positive. The heat engine or any other machine cannot produce work without releasing heat in atmosphere. May, 2009 there are two statements of the second law of thermodynamics, one due to kelvin and planck and the other due to clausius. One of the earliest statements of the second law of thermodynamics was made by r. Apr 12, 2007 hi, i got a problem in thermodynamics. This tells us that it is impossible to have 100% efficiency. Equivalence of the clausius and kelvinplanck statements. Kelvinplanck statement of the second law nuclear power. Prove that, if the kelvin planck statement of the second law of thermodynamics is false, then the clausius statement is also false.
After joules heatwork equivalence theorem was found, clausius. Kelvinplanck statement entropy and the second law before these statements, we have to remind the work of a french engineer and physicist, nicolas leonard sadi carnot advanced the study of the second law by forming a principle also called carnots rule that specifies limits on the maximum efficiency any heat engine can obtain. Clausius statement article about clausius statement by. Read the kelvin planck statement of the 2nd law for yourself. Equivalence of kelvin plank and clausius statement 2nd law of themodynamics in hindi. Kelvinplanck statement of the second law it is impossible to construct a device which operates on a cycle and produces no other effect than the production of work and the transfer of heat from a single body. Equivalence of the kelvin planks and clausius statement the two statements of second law of thermodynamics are just two different ways of explaining the same problem, i. The kelvin planck and clausius statements of the second law of thermodynamics are equivalent because a violation of one statement implies the violation of the other. The open question is whether the clausius inequality may be broken in a real experiment. Kelvin planck s statement no cyclic process is possible whose sole result is the complete conversion of heat into an equivalent amount of work. The decision between possibility i and iv is made by experimental experience 1 kelvin statement false. We can combine it with a heat pump so that the work produced by the engine is used by the pump. This is not possible kelvin planck no process is possible whose sole result is the transfer of heat from a cooler to a hotter body. The clausius and kelvinplanck statements of the second law are entirely equivalent.
It is remarkable that the two above statements of the second law are in fact. Equivalence of the clausius and kelvinplanck versions of the. Consider, a heat pump absorbs heat q1 from a cold reservoir which is at temperature t2 and transfers it to a hot reservoir which is at temperature t1 without expenditure of any work. Thermodynamics truefalse chapters 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6. This was just a summary on equivalence of the kelvin plank and clausius statements. Consider that some amount of heat is exchanged between two reservoirs having temperatures t 1 and t 2, with. What is the relation between clausius and kelvin planck statement. Ok, the new statement of the 2nd law is called the kelvin planck statement. Consider a cyclically working device 1, which absorbs energy q1 as heat from a thermal reservoir at th. Kelvin planck statement of the second law of thermodynamics. Someone who is going to test the clausius inequality needs a thermodynamic framework for the analysis.
1550 333 403 303 1648 255 347 652 1468 930 991 1294 456 617 379 671 1000 1140 1088 1333 1016 67 1672 1439 1259 465 1229 1529 1414 969 205 776 1009 1008 1469 206 79 1476 1395 135 998 716 891 1469 1225 538 1410